The one question to ask all three contractors you get quotes from
Everyone says get three quotes. Good advice. But comparing three prices is not the same as comparing three companies. Here is the question that actually tells you something.
When you get three quotes, the one question to ask every contractor is: which company and which solution lines up best with my personal goals and what I am trying to accomplish? That question moves the conversation off price alone and onto whether the contractor actually understood your priorities, your comfort issues, your budget, and how long you plan to stay in the home. The best answer comes from the company that asked you the most questions first.
Three prices is not three companies
Everybody has heard the advice to get three quotes, and it is good advice. But here is the trap. Most people line up three numbers and pick the lowest one. Comparing three prices is not the same thing as comparing three companies, and the price tells you almost nothing about whether the job will be done right.
So instead of just collecting numbers, ask each contractor one question.
The question
Ask each of them: which company and which solution lines up best with my personal goals and what I am trying to accomplish?
It sounds simple, but it does a lot of work. It forces the conversation away from a flat price and onto you, your comfort problems, your priorities, your budget, and how long you plan to be in the home. The way each contractor answers tells you who actually listened and who just wants to drop in a box and leave.
Why this question separates the good from the rest
The reason I love this question is that the right answer can only come from a company that asked you questions first. At Wahl, before we ever talk equipment, we go through what we call symptom and lifestyle questions and a happy home analysis. We are not trying to figure out the best piece of equipment in a vacuum. We are trying to figure out what would actually improve your comfort, your air quality, and how you experience living in your home.
- Are there rooms that never get comfortable?
- Does anyone in the house have asthma, allergies, or trouble with dry winter air?
- How long do you plan to stay in this home?
- What does your budget realistically look like, and what payment options matter to you?
A contractor who answers your question well will tie their recommendation back to those things. A contractor who cannot will just repeat their price.
What a good answer sounds like
A good answer is honest, even when honesty costs the contractor the sale. I once told a friend straight up that I could not get anywhere near the cheap quote he had, but that I could build him a system that actually made his home comfortable and cut his bills. That is lining the solution up with his real goals, not just hitting a number. Sometimes the honest answer is that a simpler, cheaper option fits your goals better, and a good contractor will tell you that too.
How to use the answers
Take all three answers and ask yourself which company clearly understood what you actually wanted. That is usually the one to trust, even if it is not the cheapest. The whole point is that so much of what you get in this industry comes down to which company you pick. The question puts that front and center. If you want a head start on the technical side, our buying guides like how to pick a furnace walk through what good looks like, and our about us page tells you how we think about every job.
The quick version
- Getting three quotes is good advice, but comparing three prices is not the same as comparing three companies.
- Ask each contractor which company and solution lines up best with your personal goals and what you are trying to accomplish.
- The question forces the conversation off price and onto your comfort, priorities, budget, and how long you will stay.
- Only a contractor who asked you good questions first can answer it well.
- Pick the company that clearly understood what you actually wanted, even if it is not the cheapest.
Do not just compare three prices. Ask each one which company and solution lines up best with your personal goals and desires.
The only people who can answer that well are the ones who asked you real questions first. That is the company to trust.
David WahlCEO & Master Plumber, Wahl Family
Want a Pittsburgh company that does it the right way, the first time?
Call 1-855-GET-WAHLFrequently asked questions
What is the single best question to ask a contractor for a quote?
Ask which company and which solution lines up best with your personal goals and what you are trying to accomplish. It shifts the conversation from price alone to whether the contractor understood your comfort issues, budget, and plans for the home, which is what actually determines if the job is done right for you.
Why is the lowest of three quotes not always the best choice?
Because price tells you very little about quality, sizing, or whether the contractor understood your needs. So much of what you get in this industry comes down to which company you pick. The right choice is the one whose recommendation clearly fits your goals, even if it is not the cheapest.
What questions should a good contractor ask me first?
A good contractor asks about comfort problems room by room, anyone with asthma, allergies, or dry-air issues, how long you plan to stay in the home, and your real budget and payment preferences. We call these symptom and lifestyle questions, and they come before any talk of equipment.
How many quotes should I get for an HVAC or plumbing job?
Three is a common and reasonable number. The key is to compare the companies, not just the numbers. Ask each one the same goals-based question and see who answers it by tying the solution back to what you actually want.
What does a good answer from a contractor sound like?
It sounds honest, even when honesty costs them the sale. A good contractor will connect their recommendation to your specific goals, and will tell you when a simpler or cheaper option actually fits you better. If they just repeat their price, they did not listen. See how to pick a furnace for what informed advice looks like.
For a Happy Home, Get Wahl
Pittsburgh and Allegheny County, since 1980. HVAC, plumbing, water treatment, sewer, and bathroom remodeling, all under one roof, all done the Wahl way.